Nontraditional Credit
THE USE OF ALTERNATIVE CREDIT OR NONTRADITIONAL CREDIT
Alternative Credit (Nontraditional Credit) refers to creditworthiness evaluation methods that do not rely on standard credit scores generated by traditional credit reporting agencies (Experian, Equifax, and Transunion). Instead, it uses alternative data sources to establish a consumer's ability and willingness to repay debt.
Get Credit Card
KEY FACTORS OF ALTERNATIVE CREDIT:
Payment History for Nontraditional Sources:
- Rent payments
- Utility bills (electricity, gas, water)
- Telecommunication bills (internet, phone)
- Subscription services (e.g., cable television, streaming platforms)
- Insurance premiums (e.g., car, renters, homeowners, life, health)
Bank Account Data:
- Savings patterns
- Direct deposit consistency
- Overdraft incidents
Employment and Income Stability:
- Employment history
- Verification of steady income
Other Alternative Data:
- Educational attainment
- Day-to-day financial behavior (e.g., timely daycare or gym payments)
Money Basics
Advantage
Advantages of Alternative Credit:
Inclusivity:
- Provides access to credit for individuals with limited or no credit history (e.g., immigrants, young adults, or previously unbanked individuals).
Customizable Assessments:
- Tailors credit evaluations based on consistent financial behaviors not captured in traditional credit scores.
Faster Credit Building:
- Helps individuals establish credit faster through positive reporting of nontraditional obligations.
Money Basics
Disadvantage
Disadvantages of Alternative Credit:
Limited Acceptance:
- Many lenders and institutions still prefer traditional credit scoring systems.
Privacy Concerns:
- Use of nontraditional data raises concerns about consumer privacy and data security.
Inconsistent Standards:
- Lack of uniform methods for evaluating alternative credit can lead to discrepancies among lenders.
Potential for Misinterpretation:
- Alternative data, such as income volatility, might misrepresent a consumer’s financial health.
Money Basics
Comparison to Traditional Credit Scoring:
| Aspect | Traditional Credit Scoring | Alternative Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Data Source | Credit cards, loans, and mortgages reported to bureaus | Rent, utilities, bank account activity, subscriptions |
| Inclusion Criteria | Established credit history required | No formal credit history required |
| Standardization | Uniform scoring models (e.g., FICO, VantageScore) | Nonstandard and lender-specific |
| Consumer Reach | Focuses on the credit-active population | Includes the "credit invisible" and underserved |
| Adoption | Widely adopted by lenders | Growing adoption, but less common |
Government-Sponsored Entities (GSEs) Consideration:
- Fannie Mae:
- Desktop Underwriter® (DU):
- Supports borrowers with nontraditional credit histories.
- Requires a verification of at least 12 months of timely payments for at least two nontraditional sources (e.g., rent, utilities).
- No major delinquency (e.g., 30-day late payments) on nontraditional accounts in the past 12 months.
- Freddie Mac:
- Loan Product Advisor® (LPA):
- Allows lenders to include nontraditional credit data for borrowers without traditional credit scores.
- Accepts alternative sources, such as rent and utilities, to establish creditworthiness.
- Federal Home Loan Banks (FHLBanks):
- Focuses on community-based lending programs.
- Supports affordable housing initiatives and encourages member banks to consider alternative credit factors for underserved populations.
Conclusion:
Alternative credit scoring is a valuable tool for promoting financial inclusivity and providing credit access to underserved populations. While its adoption by GSEs such as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac reflects growing acceptance, challenges like standardization and lender awareness remain.